Thursday, 30 October 2014

Legal Action Procedures - Hire Purchase Loan (Motor Vehicle) - Part 3 - Repossession


We have now come to a quite interesting topic as depicted above. There may be some "hot" scenes such as slander, defamation, car chases,  vulgarities, fist fights and we may even have some "chair throwing" sessions. Yes, sounds a lot like the current political scene and yes, we are actually "talking" about car repossession.





After taking into consideration the mandatory two months of successive defaults and the issuance of the Fourth Schedule giving the Hirer a further 21 (twenty one) days, plus a few more days allowance for the weekend, public holidays, sick leave, emergency leave and a host of other "leaves", THREE months or more has passed. Finally the Repossession Authority was issued and we assume that the car was repossessed.

For a clerk or the officer in charge, this is supposed to be a "happy moment" where the asset of the Bank has been "recovered". However, there will always be a feeling of anxiety and uncertainty of what is coming his/her way when the car, the Repossession Agents and the Hirer who may be accompanied by some "concerned" and "angry" mobs complete with sickles, torches, pitchforks and rakes just to name but a few to "discuss" matters.

Among the requirements for a Repossession Agent after repossession is to make a Police report and then proceed to the Bank for car inspection and photography session. The inspection will focus on the engine and chassis numbers of the car, the overall physical condition of the car recording whatever visible defects such cracks, dents, engine condition as well as making a list of the Hirer's personal belongings.  Upon inspection, the car will be sent to the Bank's panel storage facility who will do the same type of inspection. This is very important to protect the Bank's and the store's interest in the event of any counter claim made by the Hirer.

There are some cases where upon repossession, the car is sent to the store directly due to some security concerns and usually because the car is being chased by some angry mob where inspection will be done later at the store. For a "seasoned" clerk or officer, such situation (events after repossession) will not surprise them anymore. If there is a new clerk or officer or any staff who has just been transferred to the collection department, they will be "released"  to face the situation in order to give training in self composure, crisis management as well as to "harden" the heart. (Yeah, right). The pecking order to face the situation is more or less like the accounting principle of LIFO (Last In, First Out - most junior first) which is of course under some form of supervision (watching from a safe distance) if the situation gets out of control.

When the "party" of Repossession Agents and the Hirer most probably with his/her "entourage" finally arrived and if there is any commotion, the clerk, the officer and the"Pak Guard" (security guard) will try to diffuse the situation by being the umpire or referee of a possible slinging match. Being a referee would have its own risks and hazards where the referee may be caught in the "crosfire" or "friendly fire" or even "unfriendly fire" when adjudged to be biased by either side of the "warring" party. Whatever the case may be, when things have cooled down a bit, discussions and negotiations can commence  with each party given the chance to present their "facts of the case" and again, the Bank's representative being the "judge" (no more refereeing) on the issues raised.

Below are the excerpts of each party's chronology of events leading to the repossession based on a true story but has been "remixed" and adjusted accordingly:

REPOSSESSION AGENT'S VERSION

This morning my colleagues and I stumbled upon (Yeah right. They have been following the bloke for days to study his movement patterns) the Hirer presumably on his way to work. We followed the car and waited for a suitable time to "greet" the hirer.

When the car has been parked, we approached the hirer and greeted him with our best smiles and pleasantries. We introduced ourselves as the agent of the Bank showing him our identity cards, authority cards, certification from AHPCM and the Repossession Authority. We politely asked for the car keys and offered him to come with us to the Bank. However, despite our extreme politeness, the Hirer, without any provocation was hostile towards us and started to hurl abuses. Being sensitive guys, we were hurt by such foul language used which reminds us of the song "Hurt" by the Manhattans. (If you are below 40, you may have to look it up in Youtube). Despite the abuses, we tried our level best to persuade the Hirer to hand over the keys but the Hirer still refused to cooperate and continued with the abuses and further insulted us with the words "bloody idiots who never went to school", "lazy bumps, that's why you morons ended up with this lousy job" and other insults which we may have to sensor because of its X-rated contents as we are not used to such filthy language.

Before losing our patience and with a heavy heart we have no choice but to wrest the car keys from the Hirer while one of my colleagues gathered the Hirer's personal belongings from the car into a plastic bag before handing it over to him. We left the Hirer there since he refused to follow us to the Bank and proceeded to make a police report before coming here. We asked for a higher repossession fee due to the difficulty of taking back the car, the gangster mannerism of the Hirer and the mental and spiritual abuses we have to endure. One of my colleagues even cried while on the way here. That is our story and all of it is true.

THE HIRER'S VERSION

This morning while on the way to work I realized that a car with two or three suspicious looking characters possibly with malicious intentions was following me. After I reached my office and parking the car I was approached by two goons demanding me to get out of the car. Before I was able to react, one of them opened the car door and took the car keys from me. One of them showed me his id card and some sort of Authority card in a flash and then threw the Repossession Authority to my face. I pleaded with them to give me a chance to go to the Bank to settle the matter but they refused and hurl abuses towards me. They were very rude and the language that they used can make a grown man blush with shame.

While I was discussing with those men, another one of them took out my personal belongings and handed it to me saying if I am not satisfied, I can come to the Bank and sort it out and left me there flabbergasted. I am very sad, disappointed, stressed out and almost died of embarrassment since there were a lot people around when it happened. I know I was wrong but I don't deserved to be treated in such a way. For your information, I kept two gold bangles, a golden ring and RM2,000 under the front seat of the car and now it is gone. I demand compensation and harsh punishment for your Agents for being rude and robbing me of my valuables. I have already told my mom, the police and the village head and all my Facebook friends about this and some of them are here with me including my mom to lend me some moral support. I demand justice for me and other Hirers who may face the same predicament.

BANK OFFICER/CLERK VERSION (DEPENDING ON THE SITUATION)

I just got to know about this repossession about an hour ago since the Repossession Authority was issued by Head Office. Nowadays it is the Head Office who issues the Repossession Authority in line with Bank Negara's (Central Bank) latest guideline on tightening the loan recovery procedures (Yeah, it is always "good" to "tai chi" or "push" the blame on "Head Office" or even "Bank Negara", entities unreachable by most borrowers). We used to only "bother" about accounts that are more than three months overdue.We have no choice but to follow the guidelines. You (the hirer) have not paid a single sen towards the account despite our sms, reminders and phone calls (the first "whole truth" statement) so it is quite difficult for us to sympathize with you. 

With regards to our Agents, they have been trained to be courteous and act according to the guidelines. However, if there is a mistake made by them, we wish to apologize and shall give them a stern warning (have to "back up" the Agents if it is apparent the Hirer is pulling a fast one). On the missing items, kindly lodge a report and let the police investigate as this a very serious allegation. After discussion with the manager and after careful consideration, repossession fee is set at RM500.00 (normally the Agents will make some noise on the "low" fee but a promise of more "easy" Repossession Authority will keep them quiet for a while. They are just trying their luck most of the time) There have to be some "give and take" on the part of the Bank and Repossessors otherwise it would be quite difficult to work together.

CONCLUSION

The above scenario is just an example of a myriad of situations when a car is repossessed. You cannot trust the agent or the Hirer 100% so sometimes a bit of experience and "gut feeling" is essential to come up with the right or "almost right" or "totally screwed up" decision. With regards to the repossession fee, it depends on a lot of factors such as the amount overdue, months overdue, the degree of "difficulty" in getting the car back which may include a "buyback" deal involving  local warlords or "Don Corleones" or "Little Napoleans" or whatever "whatchamacallit"who has "jurisdiction" or a "caveat" over the car usually bought over hand to hand from a "continue payment" deal gone sour. There are also cases where it is the Agent who will take the car from the Hirer and will keep it for months for "fermentation" until it is "ripe" enough to command a higher repossession fee and of course such Agents are not tolerated and will be blacklisted by the Banks and AHPCM.

Whatever it is, when a car has been repossessed, the Bank must sent a Notice called the Fifth Schedule as provided in Section 16 (3) of the Hire Purchase Act 1967 (Amendment 2010). This is an excerpt of the Section:


The Fifth Schedule must be sent within 21 (twenty one) days from the date of repossession. Otherwise, the Bank will lose its rights in the Hire Purchase agreement. However, if  the Hirer exercises his/her right to take back the car, the Hire Purchase Agreement shall continue as if the Fifth Schedule has been sent.

In Section 17 (1) , Bank is not allowed to sell the repossessed car without the consent of the Hirer before expiry of the 21 (twenty one) days  given in the Fifth Schedule. The ones in the red box that is Section 17A and 17B are about the "permit" or permission given to the Registered Repossession Agent as discussed previously.

Below is a sample of a Fifth Schedule:



The Fifth Schedule has two main parts or rather choices given to the hirer. We shall look at the first part which is shown below:



This part gives the Hirer the opportunity to "reactivate" the Hire Purchase Agreement by paying all the arrears in instalment, late charges and other costs.



The second part gives an option to full settle the loan after taking into consideration the repossession cost, storage costs and other incidental costs after deducting the statutory "rebate" calculated beforehand. The excess or shortfall that is due to the Hirer and the Bank respectively if the car is sold at the estimated price given is also stated in the Fifth Sxhedule. The estimated market value is equivalent to "Forced Sale Value" where it depends on the condition of the car. The Bank will usually give a "conservative" value as a precautionary measure in the event the car fails to attract any bidders during the public auction.

The Hirer also has the right to give a notice in writing to the Owner/Bank within the 21 days before the expiry of the Fifth Schedule to introduce an individual who wants to buy the car at a price not less than the Fifth Schedule's estimated value in CASH. This right is provided for in Section 18 (1)(a)(ii) :



Upon expiry of the Fifth Schedule, the Bank is free to sell the car. How is it done and what is the Bank's next course of action? We shall continue in Part 4...


Tuesday, 28 October 2014

Legal Action Procedures - Hire Purchase Loan (Motor Vehicle) - Part 2

Here we are. The loan recovery procedures for Hire Purchase loan. Full slides in Powerpoint format can be obtained from here or from the Facebook Album collection here. We start with the introductory slide of our topic:



Should anybody wants more information on the "Source of Funds" kindly refer to this Facts about Digital, Physical Money and Interest/Usury

As with any other loans, we begin with a joyous occasion of getting the loan approved, money has been disbursed and the car has been delivered. The day of disbursement shall then be the day the agreement officially commences. Such a "happy" occasion can be reviewed in the previous article entitled Part 5 - The Collection Department  At this time, the Bank already "collected" the first interest/usury for the month. You can refer to Legal Action Procedures - Hire Purchase Loan (Motor Vehicle) - Part 1 for more information on the interest/usury structure.

We will make an assumption that in our example, there has been no payment received from the Hirer from the very beginning. This will make it easier to see the flow of the legal action taken. During the first month of default, the loan is still considered "new" and the Bank will give the Hirer the benefit of the doubt where the standard reminder, text messages will be sent. Phone calls will also be made to remind as well as to check whether the phone is still functioning. Late charges and reminder costs are automatically calculated.



As soon as the account is two months overdue (depending on weekends and public holidays and the person in charge is alert enough) the notice called Fourth Schedule will be printed as stipulated in the Hire Purchase Act in Section 16 giving the Hirer 21 (twenty one) days to update the arrears in instalment:




What is shown above is only part of Section 16 of the Hire Purchase Act. Section 16 in full is given below:



The Section 16 (2) above (in the red box) will be discussed in more detail in a separate topic entitled "Continue Payment". For now, we will look into the Fourth Schedule and other related notices. Below is the sample of the Fourth Schedule:



As you can see in the Fourth Schedule, if the Hirer voluntarily surrenders the vehicle, the cost of repossession, the cost incidental to taking possession and the storage cost WILL NOT be charged. After 14 (fourteen) of the issuance of the Fourth Schedule, another Notice called the Notice of Intention to Repossess will be issued which also serves as an additional reminder that the Hirer has only 7 (seven) days left to make payment failing which repossession will take place. This notice can be regarded as an additional "cushion" for the Banks that they have given enough alerts and reminders in case the Hirer makes any claim of not being "sufficiently" reminded. These notices will be sent by registered post as proof of posting to the last known address of the Hirer and Guarantor (if any) 

This is a sample of the Notice of Intention:



Please be reminded that under Section 16(1), the above notices can ONLY be sent if there is TWO SUCCESSIVE defaults in instalments (not 1 1/2 instalment or part thereof. That is why Banks may not accept partial payment unless in unavoidable circumstances for fear of "interpretation" issues in the event of disputes). Another factor to consider is that if the Hirer has paid a total of 75% of the CASH PRICE of the car, the Bank would have to apply for a Court Order in order to issue the Fourth Schedule. "What? Run that by me again" you might say. Kindly refer to the table below:



Based on the above table, the cash price of the car is RM60,000. If the Hirer has paid up to  72 months (6 years), he/she would have paid 75% of the cash price. (now this is THE "math" that is taught in schools). This also means that the Bank CANNOT issue the Fourth Schedule if the Hirer fails to pay instalments number 73 and 74 (successive) and need to apply for a Court Order to do so.  Bummer! It will be cumbersome not to mention time consuming even though the car may be parked in front of the Bank everyday. By the time the Court Order is obtained, the car may be long gone "riding on the sunset". 

However since in our example no payment is received since the inception of the loan, these Notices can therefore be issued.



We continue to the next step. After the expiry of the Fourth Schedule in 21 days, the account would have been 3 (three) months overdue. The Bank can now issue the Repossession Order or Repossession Authority to the Repossession Agents. Nowadays the Repossession Agents are required to be registered with the Association of Hire Purchase Companies Malaysia (AHPCM) . These agents will be given an "Authority Card" by the Banks as well as the certification by AHPCM as proof that they are authorized to carry on the repossession assignment. This is due to some "unpleasant" reputation of some Repossession Agents over the years with regards to the manner in which cars has been taken or in some cases, "stolen" from the Hirers.

AHPCM and the Banks has come up with quite a comprehensive guidelines of  the "Do's and Don'ts" for the Repossession Agents in order to minimize repossession incidents not according to the proper procedures. Listed beloware  the guidelines taken from AHPCM's website

CODE OF ETHICS FOR PERMIT HOLDER ON REPOSSESSION

1.     (a)   permit holders must ensure that they are in possession of current and valid permit during the course of carrying out repossession work.

        (b)   as far as possible the number of authorised permit holders performing repossession activities must be minimized unless circumstances warrant any additional assistance.

        (c)    repossession work can only be carried out daily from 9 am to 9 pm.

2.     Permit holders issued with a repossession order by owner should only gain entry into premises with the knowledge and consent of the occupant.  Trespassing into private property is not allowed without a court order obtained by the owner.

3.     Permit holders issued with a repossession order by the owner should be well mannered and dressed decently. They should ensure the practice of professionalism and dignity in carrying out their work.

4.     The use of ‘strong arm tactics’ of any kind is strictly prohibited in the performance of their work.

5.     At the time of repossession, the permit holders should:

        (a)  Produce his permit, national registration card and give a standard notice to the hirer informing him of the address and telephone number of the legal owner and the authorised officers he/she can contact immediately to resolve any problem.

        (b)   give a reasonable time to the hirer to inspect the motor vehicle or goods and remove his personal items and belongings.

        (c)    take photographs of the interior and exterior of the motor vehicle or goods and provide such photographs to the legal owner.

        (d)   cause to be issued an inventory list to state the status and the condition of the repossessed motor vehicle or goods.

6.     As far as possible repossession should be undertaken in the presence of the hirer or any person authorised to use that motor vehicle or goods.

7.   A police report on the repossession should be lodged as soon as practicable and preferably within 24 hours but in exceptional circumstances, not later than 48 hours from the time of repossession.

8.     Permit holders issued with a repossession order by owner should at all times act in accordance with the laws, regulations, terms and conditions, code of ethics and guideline issued by the Controller in the performance of their repossession activities.

9.     Permit holders should also observe any other Code of Ethics or Guidelines issued from time to time by the Controller.


I believe that the Agents have done their level best to follow the guidelines above since they know they are being watched and a slight mistake may render themselves out of the job and they themselves would prefer a "hassle free" repossession. However, in my previous article here you might still remember that the Hirers or Borrowers have their own set of "personality traits" which may invoke different reactions from these repossession agents.



The "multiple personality" factor of borrowers shall bring countless headaches to the clerks, officers and Bank managers whenever a car has been repossessed especially on the cost of repossession. Most of the time, there will be some form of drama involved and the genre of such drama may be a "tear jerker", "thriller and suspense", "Law and Order" and "Bollywood style action" but definitely no "love story" or "science fiction" here. The repossession cost will normally be hotly debated with the Hirer and Reposession Agents both giving their "submissions" to the "Judge" i.e the Bank who will make the final decision.

If only all Hirers are of the "Spongebob Squarepants" character, life would be much easier as there would not be any need for repossession at all. But then, this is the real world and not "Bikini Bottom" and life is not as simple as that.

The main objective for any repossession agent is to maximize the fees for each car they repossess as they normally operate in groups of two, three or four. For "easy" cases like two or three month overdue, within the vicinity of the Bank and an "ok" Hirer, the fees are quite standardized as determined by the Bank. Unlike some "heavy metal" stuff which normally surpassed the more than 6 (six) months overdue threshold and sometimes overdue for years coupled with the "current owner" being a "difficult" chap to deal with, then the fees are definitely higher. In some cases, the Bank has to resort to a "buy back" arrangement if it is still worth doing so (Hmm.. car repossession also got a "buy back" arrangement :)) and the amount could well reach thousands of Ringgit. The original Hirer will definitely suffer from the resulting legal action as most of the time the car has been passed around multiple times from hand to hand originating from an innocent "Continue Payment" deal gone sour. (more on that later)

Back to Reposession Agent. Maximizing their fees and getting "high success rate" Repossession Authority are their main objective. That is why they need to have a good rapport with the clerk or officer or Bank Manager who gives out the Repossession Authority. The one who gives out the Repossession Authority need to be extra careful in distributing them as giving the same Repossession Authority to multiple Agents especially the "easy ones" would be inviting trouble unless it is agreed upon themselves (for highly wanted cases) and done in an "open" manner and in the spirit of "may the best agent win"' atmosphere. There were cases of Agents fighting among themselves ala "gang war" over a Repossession Authority and some Bank staffs have been known to be assaulted over some Repossession Authority issues. Hmm... perhaps the Bank would look into giving more insurance cover and benefits for their collection staffs judging from the risk they face everyday. In the "old days" the counter clerks face more risks in terms of robbery. Nowadays robbers has gone "online" (they even managed to steal more money "at their fingertips") or prefer to steal ATM machines and some fools has also resorted to stealing Cheque Deposit Machines for whatever reason known to them. Now the collection staffs' job is far more riskier. :)

Ok. Enough of that. Below is a sample of a Repossession Authority:



We shall continue in the next section where we will discuss the events after repossession. Quite a long story....

Monday, 27 October 2014

Legal Action Procedures - Hire Purchase Loan (Motor Vehicle) - Part 1

Now we have reached a quite "popular" topic that is the legal procedures for car loan recovery. Why? Because most people have cars either brand new or used and most are bought through Bank loans. Out of necessity of course! A "new" car today will be classified as "used" immediately upon registration. Those with loan terms of 7 and 9 years are still paying through their noses or already starting new loans through refinancing (if the car still got some value) or buying a new car when the old loan has been settled in full. 
Before we proceed with the car loan recovery procedures, there are a few things that you need to know.
All car purchases made through Bank loans are governed by the provisions of the Hire Purchase Act 1967 (latest amendments 2010) which is under the purview of the Ministry of Domestic Trade, Co-operatives and Consumerism (MDTCC). The Act has undergone numerous amendments and adjustments to protect the rights of consumers or to be exact, the "Hirer" as well as the "Owner" that is the Bank giving the loan. There are at least 32 offences cited in this Act which covers the Owner giving blank Second Schedule (Part 1 and 2) and the  Hire Purchase Agreement to be signed by the Hirer, the agent or Owner not collecting the minimum deposit of 10%, fraudulent sale of the car by Hirer (usually through "Continue Payment" arrangement), failure in the part of the Owner to give the statutory Notices (Fourth and Fifth Schedule), non disclosure of facts and a host of other wrongdoings. Based on the examples given, you can judge for yourself that the Act has been abused with impunity all this while. 

The various penalties for anybody who is found guilty of committing offences under this Act are listed below: 

FALSE STATEMENT BY DEALERS, etc., IN PROPOSALS

Section 36. Where—

(a) a dealer, an agent or a person on behalf of an owner prepares or causes to be prepared a hire-purchase agreement or offer in writing that, if accepted, will constitute a hire-purchase agreement with the intention of bringing about a contractual relationship between an owner and a hirer; and 

(b) the agreement or offer contains to the knowledge of the dealer, agent or person acting on behalf of the owner, as the case may be, a false statement or representation that is false in any material particular, the dealer, agent or person acting on behalf of the owner shall be guilty of an offence under this Act and shall, on conviction, be liable to a fine not exceeding ten thousand ringgit or to imprisonment for a term not exceeding twelve months or to both.

FRAUDULENT SALE OR DISPOSAL OF GOODS BY HIRER

Section 38. Every person who, by the disposal or sale of any goods comprised in a hire-purchase agreement, or by the removal of the goods, or by any other means, defrauds or attempts to defraud the owner shall be guilty of an offence under this Act and shall, on conviction, be liable to a fine not exceeding thirty thousand ringgit or to imprisonment for a term not exceeding three years or to both.

PENALTY NOT EXPRESSLY PROVIDED FOR

Section 46. (1) Any person who is guilty of an offence under this Act or any regulations made thereunder for which no penalty is expressly provided shall, on conviction, be liable—

(a) if such person is a body corporate, to a fine not exceeding one hundred thousand ringgit, and for a second or subsequent offence, to a fine not exceeding two hundred and fifty thousand ringgit;

(b) if such person is not a body corporate, to a fine not exceeding twenty-five thousand ringgit or to imprisonment for a term not exceeding three years or to both, and for a second or subsequent offence, to a fine not exceeding fifty thousand ringgit or to imprisonment for a term not exceeding five years or to both.

(2) Where a person, being a director, manager or an officer concerned in the management of the body corporate or was purporting to act in such capacity, is guilty, by virtue of section 47, of an offence under this Act or any regulations made thereunder for which no penalty is expressly provided, he shall be liable to the penalty provided for under paragraph (1)(b).

Section 47. Where any offence under this Act has been committed by anybody corporate (whether or not the body corporate has been prosecuted) any person who at the time of the commission of the offence was a director, manager or an officer concerned in the management of the body corporate or was purporting to act in such capacity shall be deemed to be guilty of that offence unless he proves that the offence was committed without his consent or connivance and that he exercised all such diligence to prevent the commission of the offence as he ought to have exercised having regard to the nature of his functions in that capacity and to all the circumstances of the case.

PRINCIPAL CRIMINALLY LIABLE FOR ACTS OF SERVANT OR AGENT

Section 48. Where the agent or servant of a person commits an offence, or does anything or omits to do anything (which if done or omitted to be done by that person would constitute an offence under this Act) that person shall notwithstanding that he has no knowledge of the offence be deemed guilty of the offence and be liable to punishment for the offence unless he proves that—

(a) the act or omission complained of was not within the ordinary scope of the employment of the agent or servant; or

(b) the act or omission complained of was done or omitted to be done without his consent or connivance and that he exercised all such diligence to prevent the commission as he ought to have exercised having regard to all the circumstances of the case.

OBSTRUCTION OF OFFICERS

Section 51. (1) Any person who—

(a) wilfully obstructs any officer appointed under this Act acting in pursuance of this Act;

(b) wilfully fails to comply with any requirement properly made to him by such an officer under section 50; or

(c) without reasonable cause fails to give such an officer so acting any other assistance or information which he may reasonably require of him for the purpose of the performance of his functions under this Act, shall be guilty of an offence and shall, on conviction, be liable to a fine not exceeding thirty thousand ringgit or to imprisonment for a term not exceeding three years or to both.

(2) If any person, in giving any such information as is mentioned in the preceding subsection, makes any statement which he knows or has reason to believe to be false, he shall be guilty of an offence and shall, on conviction, be liable to the penalty mentioned in that subsection

As you can see, the penalties and fines are quite hefty. Like I said before, the main purpose of the Hire Purchase Act is to protect the Owner/Bank as well as the Hirers especially the ones who buy used cars in terms of protection against cars that do not meet specifications or cars with hidden defects, "chopped" or "frankenstein" cars and stolen cars. The Act also protects against improper procedures on loan processing, repossession and legal action. In 2010, some amendments even though excellent in its intention in added protection, is deemed to be too protective and in certain cases is impractical in its implementation, according to some quarters. As a result, the new provisions caused problems to consumers, the Banks and the car dealers to a point that car buying and loan processing has become so slow and frustrating.

For the consumers, it caused problems especially to those who want the car "yesterday" especially during festive season (very very important to some people) but at the same time, they also want full protection from the Act  when they got into trouble even though they (the Hirer) are also guilty of breaking the rules in one way or the other whether they realized it or not. I do not want to comment too much on this as the affected parties has already discussed this matter at length with the authorities and their grouses are easily searchable with the ever accommodating Mr Google.

I want to "talk" about the loan recovery process for car loan in accordance with the provisions of the Hire Purchase Act 1967 (latest amendment 2010) and some other related issues such as "Continue Payment", failure to state the current location of the car  and the like. As I have mentioned earlier, in a Hire Purchase Agreement, as long as the loan remain unpaid, the borrower is called the "Hirer" and the Bank is the real "Owner" of the car where the ownership claim is prominently displayed in the registration card.

Normally the interest/usury rate for a Hire Purchase agreement is of the "flat rate" type even though the "variable rate" type based on the Base Lending Rate (BLR) is also available as another option where a certain percentage point will be added to the BLR. The interest/usury rate structure is provided for under what is known as the "Sixth Schedule" as shown below:



The above calculation is closely related to the "rebate" or a discount that is given for the balance of total interest not yet due when the Hirer wants to make an early settlement for the loan. We shall take an example from the loan details below:



Assuming that the Hirer wants to settle the loan by the 36th month, the formula for rebate calculation is:


Based on the above calculation, the rebate or discount given is RM8036.70 and this amount is valid until the next due date. If the cutoff date has expired, the rebate for the next due date will be calculated for the following month which is for payment number 37 and so on.

During my younger days, the rebate is calculated manually and you can show it to the Hirer if he/she is not satisfied by just looking at the precalculated figure in the ledger. This is the main bone of contention between the Hirer and the Bank whenever there is a full settlement request. The usual dialogue is " I have paid a lot of money already, why is the balance so high? I'm a math teacher you know and I have done my own calculations! (based on a true story) The answer is "This is the math of usury. The name of this calculation is the"Rule of 78" or the "Sum of the Digits" (that is the sum of 1+2+3+4+5+6+...+12 = 78) that is a formula created in the 1920s before the existence of the calculator. The main purpose is to enable the creditors to maximize their profit where a large portion of interest/usury will be collected during the early stages of the loan. So the Bank will whack the interest/usury during the early years (approximately 75% of interest/usury up to the halfway mark of the loan) . Only towards the end  a larger portion of the principal will be collected. That is why dear math teacher, you will not find the answer in your "normal" textbook." 

Not too many people know about this as most of the computations are done with the computer. To have a bit of understanding, you can refer to the table shown below:



A Hire Purchase Agreement commences as soon as the Bank pays the car dealer or the previous owner of the car for the price of the car which includes the first year of insurance premium for a new car. If, for whatever reason the Hirer decides that he/she wants to return or sell the car and would like to make full settlement, even after a few hours, he/she will be charged interest/usury of RM330.28 and the "new" car he/she has bought, has already become a "second hand" car and shall lose a few thousand Ringgit more. That is the fact that has to be accepted.

You can also see for yourself, even up to the third year, a large portion is still "reserved" for interest/usury. That is the interest structure that has been molded into the Hire Purchase Act  which is the "Rule of 78" as what I have mentioned previously. However, it is not clearly stated in the Act as you can see here:



In your opinion, how many people can actually understand the "calculation method" given above? Yes, not many. There used to be a detailed formula but not anymore. Perhaps it is deemed unnecessary in the age of advanced technology we live in where everything is "at your fingertips". No more manual calculation in the "good old days" which is actually good in terms of understanding what the heck you are doing. You can bet your life's possession that not many "new age" Bankers actually know how to calculate the rebate manually. There are some Hirers who will insist on seeing and understanding how the formula works and I would love to see the look on their faces if confronted with such situation. Some will just say that if the computer prints it, it must be right and if the Hirer still insists, they will have to look for the "old timers" or the "old school" colleagues, that is if they still exist. Some have gone their own way after the massive "golden handshake" exercise during the financial crisis of 1997.

Whatever the case may be, that is the fact of the matter whether it is Hire Purchase Loan, Housing Loan, Personal loan, Credit Card Loan or whatever loan the Bank may call it, the interest/usury must be "cleared" first so that it will be easier to sue the borrowers (in the event of default) on the maximum amount of principal and maximize the late or penalty charges and upon obtaining Judgment, charge further interest on the maximized amount.

That shall be the introduction for the "interest-ing" topic on the Hire Purchase Act 1967 (latest amendment 2010). We can now proceed to the Loan Recovery Procedures for Hire Purchase Loan with special focus on motor vehicle in Part 2 of the series...







Saturday, 30 August 2014

Legal Action Procedures: Personal Loan Part 3

EXECUTION OF JUDGMENT

In the last post we have learned about the process of obtaining Judgment from the Court. So we will show the previous info graphic to refresh your memory.



As you can see, there are a few options available for the Bank to "persuade" or "force" the borrower to pay through the execution of Judgment together with the estimated time frame for each action. We will examine each method one by one.

BANKRUPTCY 

If the Judgment sum together with the accumulated late charges (after Judgment) and cost added together comes up to at least RM30,000, the decision is straightforward that is the execution of Judgment by way of Bankruptcy action. This is the most feared action for most borrowers because their "freedom" will be taken away and "frozen" as detailed below:

1) All his/her financial matters will be administered by the Official Assignee (OA) appointed by the Jabatan Insolvensi Malaysia (Malaysian Insolvency Department)

2) His/her Bank account will be frozen until given the consent by the OA to be activated.

3) The Bankrupt would have to submit or reveal a detailed list of his/her assets and liabilities including monthly expenses. The OA will then decide (after discussion of course) how much from the monthly income to be deducted to service the outstanding loan.

4) A Bankrupt cannot hold any position (directorship, partnership, sole proprietorship) in a company meaning he or she will not be able to do any registered business

5) A Bankrupt cannot travel outside Malaysia without the written consent from the Director General of the Insolvency Department. For those who wants to perform the Haj, it is however allowed only once. A bankrupt is required to surrender his/her international passport to the Insolvency Department.

6) The OA will also conduct a check on the Bankrupt's loan status with other Banks and will include ALL of them in their records. That simply means that when other Banks find out about the Bankrupt's status, they will file a document called "Proof of Debt" where all liabilities of the Bankrupt will be grouped together and unless until all of the outstanding sum is settled, a discharge will not be given. Anybody can file this document. Imagine if during the younger days the Bankrupt used to bully the old ice cream man or the local "roti" seller by taking ice cream and bread without paying, they too can file the "Proof of Debt" if they are still alive and pissed enough to do so. That is an extreme example but it can happen. You never know...

Those are some of the "privileges" of being a Bankrupt but he/she may still work as usual but need to keep on paying the monthly commitment with the OA. We should be thankful that we have our independence. Some people told me that during the British rule, a Bankrupt is only allowed to wear a "singlet", short pants and slippers to reflect his "status" in the society. We have no idea if there is a female version of a Bankrupt during that time. Correct me if I'm wrong. This is only based on hearsay.

With a lot of "pain" and inconveniences of being a Bankrupt, this is the "best" and most potent weapon of the Banks (that is if the person is "worth" something to pay the debt). What if the outstanding amount is less than RM30,000 or almost RM30,000 with "so near yet so far" situation? If it is almost RM30,000, the Bank can wait for a little while until the interest gained reach the "magic" number. We shall discuss in length the Bankruptcy procedures in another posting (otherwise this post will be much longer and some of you are complaining about long articles. Too lazy to read they say...). In short, it will take approximately 6 (SIX) to 8 (EIGHT) months to "successfully" make a person a Bankrupt if everything goes "well".

WRIT OF SEIZURE AND SALE 

A problem will arise when the Judgment sum is too far from the magical figure of RM30,000 and if the Bank wants to wait for the interest to be enough to cover for it, it will take too long and the senior officers would have been retired by then. Therefore another alternative would have to be taken to "persuade" the borrower to make payment. We can see from the graphic below regarding a Judgment sum of RM14,000, with an interest rate of 6% and the time taken to reach the figure of more than RM30,000:


You can see for yourself that even at a compounded rate of interest, it would take a bit more than 13 (THIRTEEN) years or we can take a "ballpark figure" of  14 (FOURTEEN) years to reach RM30,000 while knowing the limit for Judgment execution is only 12 (TWELVE) years.  So the next course of action would probably be the execution of Judgment by way of "Writ of Seizure and Sale" that is loosely translated as an Order from the Court to seize the belongings in the borrower's place of residence or house and auctioning it to recover the outstanding sum. It is part of the "Writ of Execution" (If you want a detailed explanation, please ask your local Mr Lawyer. It is not the scope of this post and this is not a course in Law. In the context of this post, this is deemed sufficient to give a bit of general explanation)

In this case, the Bank can make an application to the Court for an Order to seize the property or belongings that is believed to be the borrower's and contained inside the borrower's house. The belongings shall not include the clothes the borrower wears at that point of time (Hard luck if you are clad in a towel after a shower), wife and kids and whatever that is deemed reasonable for the borrower's use including undergarments, handphone (so you won't miss your Facebook updates), cooking utensils and the "tools of the trade" that is the equipment that may be essential for the borrower to earn a living up to the value of RM200. I do not know whether this amount has been amended to "keep up with the times" but I won't waste my time checking because normally this is not followed strictly based on compassionate grounds since the main purpose is not so much on the auctioning off the belongings (not much can be gained anyway unless the belongings are indeed valuable) but to embarrass the borrower to make payment.

When the Order is obtained, the Bank officer, accompanied by the Court Bailiff will visit the borrower's house and will list all the belongings inside the house that is deemed valuable and give an estimation of their values (normally about 50% of actual value) and get a total sum. The borrower then will be given 14 (FOURTEEN) days to settle the Judgment sum or negotiate a payment proposal failing which the goods and belongings will be sold at a public auction. A security guard will be stationed at the house to make sure that no belongings are taken out of the house during the period and the borrower will also be required to pay for the guard's personalized security "services"

When doing this sort of action, always keep in mind that some items which may look "valuable" like the brand new 90 inch 3D LED TV and the state of the art Home Theatre System may not really "belongs" to the borrower. They may still belong to a creditor for example Courts Mammoth or Seng Heng and CANNOT be seized unless you can sell them more than their outstanding amount which is impossible. If those items were recently purchased during the Raya or Eid celebrations with the "pay three months later" promotion, then not even a single cent or "sen" has been paid. Another factor that needs to be considered is that the borrower may claim that the household items does not belong to him/her but his/her spouse, mother, father, grandfather, family friend or the cat or whatever entity he/she can think of. The Bank officer would have to be very cautious in assessing the situation.

In this kind of situation, there are bound to be commotions and tensions due to the "embarrassment" factor especially with the neighbours (the nosy ones, of course with their own local gossip Facebook Page and a smartphone in hand) not to mention the "price" given for the household items. However, as mentioned earlier, usually not much items that is of value can actually be gathered and recorded. The Bank may eventually has only a few useless and worn out items in the inventory and obviously it may not worth the effort. To get the Order is one thing as it may take a long time especially in major towns like Kuala Lumpur as well as the "difficulty" in "booking" the services of the Court Bailiff is another as there are not many of them around. The Bank can only hope that the borrower is embarrassed enough to find a way to make payment otherwise the Bank would have to proceed with the auction of "worthless" junks. This is where the role of the Bank's "CSI" team is very important in making preliminary assessment. 

This action (Writ of Seizure and Sale) is "best" used on a company's premises and a company that is still doing business. At least the items in the premises is more or less "confirmed" to be belonging to the company concerned and at the very least, the Bank can seal the entrance for 14 (FOURTEEN) days. If the company has a good reputation and is still doing business, it will definitely negotiate a payment settlement. A case in point happens to, ironically to a well known Bank where the Bank has been sued by one of its customers. The customer is a partner in a company which has substantial amount of money in an account with the Bank. His other partner passed away and the Bank refused to release the money to the other partner hence the suit was filed. The partner won and proceeded with the Writ of Seizure and Sale and the Bank's premises was sealed with the staffs and some customers still inside. Needless to say, the Bank settled the matter immediately. For an individual, based on the factors aforementioned , it is quite difficult with the risk of not getting anything except for incurring more costs.

GARNISHEE ORDER 

This is an "ambush" method where an Order will be served to anybody (usually a Bank) or a person who has money due to be paid to the borrower. In case of a Bank, the Order will be served when it is perceived that the money is already credited to the borrower's account. In case of a company or individual, if it is determined that there is payment is to be made to the borrower, the Order can be served to the company or individual BEFORE it has been paid to the borrower. Therefore, in either case, whatever amount available will have to be surrendered to the Bank initiating the action and if there is an excess, it will be refunded to the borrower. This method is risky because if the timing is not right or the amount is not "right", it may be just be an exercise of futility. On top of that, there are certain restrictions as to what can be garnished using this method as detailed below:

1) You cannot use this method against the Government

2) Monthly salary due to the borrower CANNOT be garnished as it will contradict Section 31 of the Employment Act 1955 which gives protection to employees in terms of their salaries.

3) Borrower is deceased

4) Under Section 11, Workmen's Compensation Act 1952, any compensation due to the borrower cannot be garnished. ("Save as provided by this Act, no lump sum or half-monthly payment payable under this Act shall in any way be capable of being assigned or charged or be liable to attachment or pass to any person other than the workman by operation of law nor shall any claim be set off against the same.")

5) Under Section 41 (2) Employees’ Social Security Act 1969  which states that "no cash benefit including invalidity grant or contributions payable under this Act shall be liable to attachment or sale in execution of any decree or order of any court."

As you can see for yourself, this method of execution may "fall flat in your face" due to the wrong timing of serving as the Bank cannot "force" the Court to come up with the Order to their liking and the time taken may well be after the money to be garnished has changed hands and spent by the borrower. The strategy must be well planned and highly accurate and again, the "CSI" department must have "top notch" information otherwise it will be a total waste of time and more cost incurred.

JUDGMENT DEBTOR SUMMONS (JDS)

This type of action is seldom used as it involves the possibility of putting the borrower in jail. What a "good" prospect as some might say especially for those borrowers who are a "pain in the ass" to deal with but it is not that simple. What the Bank wants is a "win win" situation and a "lose lose" or "in your face" situation for the borrower. That means for the clerk or officer handling the "pain in the ass" case, wouldn't it be good if they can get the payment and the borrower goes to jail? (As in the monopoly game, "Go directly to Jail, Do Not Pass GO, Do Not Collect $200)

Unfortunately, you cannot have the cake and eat it at the same time. The Court may send the borrower to jail but the Bank won't get the money because that is the reason the borrower went to jail in the first place! On top of that, all the "expenses" that is the "meal allowances" (at least three times a day) for the borrower will have to be paid by the Bank.

The Bank would have to think carefully before invoking this action because its reputation is at stake. While on the positive side it may be good to be seen as a "no nonsense" Bank, it could also bring negative side effects. The Bank may be perceived as a "cruel beast" imprisoning non paying borrowers (while it is okay for the same "cruel beast" creating money out of thin air and charging interest on top of that due to the capitalistic economic system of dependency) especially during these times of the "boycott" phenomenon. They would not risk the fate of a well known Bank recently being condemned for closing the account of a few Islamic charitable organizations that contribute to the cause of the Palestinians. Some has called for concerted withdrawal of their facilities with the Bank or a mini "Bank Run". What is odd however, is that this Bank's "Islamic" or "Syariah Compliance" department which has been certified "Halal" previously has been declared "Haram" or "Not Permissible in Islam" even though its so called Islamic "modus operandi" is EXACTLY the same with the other Banks... Hmm... So the Banks normally would have to be careful with its actions in order to avoid a similar fate or risk a boycott or even a total Bank run with the powerful social media at its mercy.

Ok. Sorry to digress a bit from the topic of Judgment Debtor Summons (JDS). We now go to the process of this particular action. It goes like this:

1) The borrower will be "summoned" to appear in Court to give a detailed information (with documentary evidence) of his/her monthly income and expenses and will be assessed on his/her capacity to pay the outstanding loan amount.

2) When the Court or rather the Judge is satisfied that the borrower has the capacity to pay a certain amount towards the outstanding sum, a "Consent Order" will be issued to the borrower if he/she consented to the arrangement. However, an "Order of the Court" can also be issued when there is no consent recorded requiring the borrower to settle the Judgment sum in full or by monthly instalments.

3) If the borrower fails to appear in Court after the service of JDS, a Warrant or Order of Arrest will be issued against him/her.

4) In the event the borrower fails to adhere to the Order of the Court or Consent Order, a notice called a "Judgment Notice" will be issued against him/her  requiring the borrower to explain the reason why he/she fails to comply with the Order of the Court and convince the Court why he/she should not be sent to jail for non compliance.

There you go. It sounds and looks "brutal" enough. But one has to remember one thing. The Magistrate or the Judge is, well, a normal human being after all and has feelings. There are some who will strictly "go by the book" but most of the time will sympathise with the borrower. Some will see it as "a big bully of a Bank" trying to squeeze the last drop of money from a "teeny weeny" borrower. Those borrowers who are well advised or with some sense of creativity will come with more documentary evidence of expenses than income especially those doing their own business coupled with a heart wrenching story akin to a "Bollywood" movie. The borrower may come with ragged clothes, unkempt hair, an unshaven look and to add some "flavour", may also do away with armpit deodorant to amplify the "hardship and suffering" effect. Coming with a wheelchair might have another "wow" effect. The Bank officer and Mr Lawyer may even cry and sob uncontrollably.

However, it is also advisable not to overdo it. The "Stinking Armpit Move" and other moves may backfire and turn out to be an "anti climax" if the Magistrate or the Judge could not stand the stench and may end the session abruptly thus depriving the borrower to deliver his/her "heart wrenching" story. Whatever the results may be, normally this mode of execution is less effective and even if there is payment decided by the Court, it may be too little from the perspective of the Bank. A potential waste of time and probably some wasted tears. 

So Ladies and Gentlemen, those are ("briefly") the procedures involved in the execution of Judgment against borrowers. With regards to Bankruptcy Proceedings, we shall discuss it in a specific post since this is the most common action taken by the Banks and it involves very specific rules and procedures. 

The next question would be, if the borrower has money, how do they make payment after Judgment has been obtained? Keep on reading.....

MAKING PAYMENT AFTER JUDGMENT

When talking about making payment after Judgment, there are a few things you need to know. There are some of you who only wants to pay only RM50.oo a month so that the Bank receives only a small amount. A sort of "in your face" kind of payment which is actually not a very smart move which we will see in a short while. Lets say the details of the Judgment obtained are as follows:

Judgment Date   :      15 Jun 2014
Judgment Sum   :    RM14,000.00
Interest Rate       :    6% a year until full settlement
Other Cost            :    RM600

Therefore if the borrower intends to pay RM50.00 (most probably under the Order of the Court, as the Bank would not accept this kind of proposal) as a "serve them right" or "in your face" kind of payment, we shall see what will happen and how the payment is treated and its calculation.


As you can see from the above example, the payment of RM50.00 is not even enough to cover the calculated monthly interest so the Judgment balance will increase and the interest will be calculated on the "new" Judgment balance. Please also note that the cost will remain the same until a substantial amount is paid to cover the whole sum. Some Banks will deduct the cost first so in this case, it will take 6 (SIX) months to cover for the cost and the Judgment interest will be calculated for six months and definitely the RM50.00 will not be able to cover the interest as well. Therefore the Judgment sum will never be settled and the interest will perpetually increase. So much for the "in your face" payment where it will instead fall flat on the face of the borrower.

For the Bank, it would not be too much trouble nowadays to treat such small payment unlike the "good old days" where things were done manually. Even so, it is not difficult to do as it only involves taking out a "dummy ledger" and recording the payment and interest and issuing a receipt. Therefore if the borrower is serious in settling the Judgment sum, he/she should negotiate a discount on the interest charged as the cost is usually non negotiable since the Bank has already paid for it. The Bank usually will ask for an upfront payment which would be able to cover at least 30% to 50% of the Judgment sum so the subsequent interest can be reduced. The proposed monthly instalment after the lump sum payment should be able to cover for the monthly interest and reduce the Judgment sum as well. If you want to win against the Bank you may win some of the time but the Bank will "win" most of the time.  Every time you take a loan, your name will be forever recorded in the Banks' computer system and some other third party information system as well as in the Central Bank's system. When you are being sued by the Bank, it will also be recorded in CTOS (Credit Tip Off Service - A Private company) for the Banks' future reference.

However, there exist some "backdoor" loans (besides loan shark "facilities") that can be obtained by "blacklisted" and Bankrupt borrowers as evident by the various advertisements for personal and car loans with the tagline "Blacklisted and Bankrupts" can also apply. How do they do it?  We shall discuss it in further detail in yet another post.

In conclusion, Ladies and Gentlemen, after going through the procedures of the execution of Judgment, you should understand by now that the best avenue for the Bank or rather the "easiest" course of action would be by way of Bankruptcy proceedings as it is the least "troublesome" and the one with the highest impact although it requires an outstanding sum of at least RM30,000. However, judging from the price of cars and houses nowadays some reaching hundreds of thousands and even millions, it should not be a "problem". The "problem" is with the amount less than the "magical" figure of RM30,000 as we have seen previously. It can be a personal loan or a shortfall or balance from the auction of a car or a house which still need to be collected.

This is where the Debt Collection Agency plays an important part as a "support group" for a more effective debt collection. This is more or less a "symbiotic" relationship between the Bank and the Collection Agency. As what I have mentioned before in previous articles, there are Banks who appointed the Debt Collection Agencies on a commission basis and there are Banks who "sold" the debt at a discounted "price" depending on each Banks' collection policy. The legality of such deal is still open for debate but since some loan agreement may have included this option, it may not be a big issue after all.

The main issue would be on the subject of selling off bad debts which has been written off and may have "expired" due to the restriction as provided in the Limitation Act and the basis of selling and collection would be on "best effort basis". A lot of people has been harassed for such debts by the Collection Agencies without knowing that the debt has expired and the Banks or the Collection Agencies have no right to collect the debt anymore. Even though "morally" the borrowers are still obligated to pay but the matter is up to the "discretion" of the borrower now as the borrower may want to pay only the principal sum and a "little bit" of "reasonable" interest. The matter can be settled amicably when the borrower has the capacity to pay to clear his/her name. If any one of you (meaning you the reader) has been harassed for a debt that is at least more than 6 (SIX) years since the last instalment paid, it is better to check with the Bank whether there is any legal action ongoing or check whether there is any Judgment obtained against you and check whether the judgment is still "alive" or more than 12 years WITHOUT any execution of Judgment. Bring a lawyer if you have to. The Collection Agencies are required to follow certain guidelines even though some claimed that their collection techniques resembles that of a loan shark.

Another point worth mentioning is that it is very important not to sever any ties with the Bank as you need to know what they are up to even though some of you would prefer to perform the "disappearing act". However, the "disappearing act" technique may haunt you later especially during a Bankruptcy proceeding where the chances to do some "time wasting maneuvers" may not be available until its too late. So stay in touch even though through a "proxy". "So near yet so far" kind of relationship.

WHAT ABOUT GUARANTORS?

The last question for this post. What about the guarantor? What will happen to them? The info graphic below has the answer.



I just want to add a bit of information. If a guarantor is the spouse of the borrower, it can be said that it is "the norm" or "acceptable" since there is a "sharing of benefit" unless the spouse has no knowledge about the loan as this also happens sometimes. If there is a divorce (some are caused by the loan itself) there would seem to be a problem of determining who is "responsible" but by law both are equally liable.

As for the "social" guarantor like being a guarantor for a friend or amongst siblings, it is more complicated. If the borrower suddenly "decides" to disappear, then the guarantor would have his/her life turned upside down. There is a Malay saying which literally means  "carrying a live monitor lizard" or "carrying an unnecessary burden" or something to that effect and that is exactly what it is. If among siblings, at the very least there is a chance to see them during festive season but among friends, I wish you good luck. So the next time somebody asked you to be a guarantor, think very, very carefully before signing on the dotted line. A friend of mine was asked to be a guarantor but due to his ignorance, he was instead "turned" into a borrower and now would have to bear the burden of paying the loan. So be careful before giving your identity card to anybody and I do mean anybody. People can fake savings account, Income Tax forms and other loan "documents" and all they need is an accomplice in the Bank to "manufacture" the loan. You may become a victim of a loan scam. A lot of guarantors has been declared a Bankrupt for "nothing" where they received no benefit whatsoever except for a tarnished reputation as a "bad person" in the eyes of the Banking sector.

Well, this is the end of quite a long post on the Legal Action and procedures for a Personal Loan. For housing and vehicle loan, there is a slight difference in the steps taken as both have their own sets of Laws or Acts to adhere to. The end result is the same after Judgment is obtained after the auction of the vehicle or the house where there is a shortfall (depending on some conditions). We shall discuss in detail in another post (again!). For the time being, digest this one first....